80 years later we know that expert rule doesn’t work, but Lippmann’s challenge to the fundaments of democracy remains unanswered. I sure don’t know how. Everything he says is correct. The best I can do is “well it seems to work anyway”.
Lippmann’s analysis of how people form opinions, and how this process may be manipulated, inspired Edward Bernays to create the PR industry. Edward Bernays inspired Goebbels, but Goebbels could just have skipped the middleman: Public Opinion contains all the building blocks of a theory of mass manipulation.
I’m too hard on Lippmann. He wanted government experts to protect us from manipulation. But it was implicit in his distrust of democracy and individual judgment that, to do that, the government must itself manipulate. And Public Opinion told it exactly how.
Today the book is mostly forgotten, but its ideas permeate every aspect of our lives. They’re there in every political statement, every advertisement, every press release. We live in the world Lippmann describes, and more so because only the wrong people listened to his ideas. Read Public Opinion yourself to restore the balance.