Monthly Archives: July 2009

Until the politically impossible becomes politically inevitable

“I’ve been meaning to read this one,” the clerk at the bookstore says when I buy Milton Friedman’s Capitalism and Freedom. That’s unexpected. It feels like a secret handshake. Perhaps we’re both members of the underground society of people who find that the classics of the libertarian tradition are relevant, not as infallible guides but as a source of ideas, a default to make carefully justified exceptions from. “Everything should be free, except..”

Some of the arguments in this 1962 book feel contemporary, such as when Friedman discusses the pros and cons of voucher-based education, or the side effects of license-based occupations. Others do not, such as when he argues against anti-discrimination laws from a purely economic standpoint. The achilles heel of much libertarian philosophy is that a policy may be economically inefficient, but still worth doing for other reasons.

What I admire here is the search for policies that are more compatible with freedom, and work as well as or better than policies that rely on compulsion. That search should be kept alive.

Personally I find Hayek more relevant today than Friedman. Friedman is an economist, Hayek a philosopher, whose ideas about information and complexity in an economic system are subtler than Friedman’s practically oriented “the market could do this better”-arguments.

Still, anyone who wants to be politically relevant today must be familiar with both these and other thinkers of the liberal and libertarian traditions. (At the very least it may help you to avoid embarassing strawman mistakes.)

40′s movies marathon – part 15

Dumbo (1941, USA) – Hey, this is brilliant! Not because of the story, but because of all the perfect scenes and details on the way. This is how Disney conquered the world, (after declaring their intentions with Fantasia.) Watched it all.

All Through the Night
(1941, USA) – The gangster movie is dead, but the corpse is shambling along as a parody of itself. This time it’s gangsters vs nazis. Oh brother. Watched: 12 minutes.

Two-Faced Woman (1941, USA) – Sleaze-bag rich guy Melvyn Douglas meets, gets skiing lessons from, and marries, Greta Garbo as Ninotchka, all within 8 minutes. Watched: 8 minutes. IMDB verdict: “They fool around on a dance floor!!!!!” (Count the exclamation marks.)

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1941, USA) – It’s ironic that this story has remained so popular, while Victorian morality hasn’t. Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde is Victorian morality. Keep your emotions under the lid, or you’ll release your lustful inner beast. But then, doesn’t all horror reflect old-fashioned morals? Anyway, it’s a good story, and I like that Spencer Tracy doesn’t play Hyde in silly monster makeup. Watched it all.

49th Parallel (1941, UK) – Hey America, look! This war of ours can come to your front steps as well! How about giving us a hand, eh? Watched: 15 minutes.